Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo, Thomas J. Bossert, Jim Sherry, and Margaret E Kruk. “
A synthesis of implementation science frameworks and application to global health gaps.”
Global Health Research and Policy 4, no. 25 (2019).
Publisher's VersionAbstractBackground: Implementation science has been growing as discipline in the past decades, producing an increasing number of models in the area. On the other hand, most frameworks are intended to guide the implementation of programs, focusing on identifying elements and stages that increase their success. This article aims to structure this discussion, proposing a simplified tool that synthesizes common elements of other frameworks, and highlight the usefulness to use implementation science not only in identifying successful implementation strategies but as a tool to assess gaps in global health initiatives.
Methods: The study was carried out through a combined methodology that included an initial search of implementation science frameworks, experts’ opinions, and the use of references in frameworks to elaborate a list of articles to be reviewed. A total of 52 articles were analyzed, identifying their definitions of implementation science and the elements of different frameworks.
Results: The analysis of articles allowed identifying the main goals and definitions of implementation science. In a second stage, frameworks were classified into “time-based”, “component-based” and “mixed”, and common elements of each type of model were used to propose a synthetic framework with six elements: Diagnosis, Intervention provider/ system, Intervention, Recipient, Environment, and Evaluation. Finally, this simplified framework was used to identify gaps in global health was using The Lancet Global Health Series. Potential areas of intervention arise for five different global health issues: malaria, non-communicable diseases, maternal and child health, HIV/AIDS, and tuberculosis. Prioritization strategies differ for the different health issues, and the proposed framework can help identify and classify all these different proposals.
Conclusions: There is a huge variety of definitions and models in implementation science. The analysis showed the usefulness of applying an implementation science approach to identify and prioritize gaps in implementation strategies in global health.
s41256-019-0115-1.pdf Chaumont, Claire, Carlo Oliveira, Enrique Chavez, Jaime Valencia, and Pablo Villalobos Dintrans. “
Out-of-pocket expenditures for HIV in the Dominican Republic: findings from a community-based participatory survey.”
Pan American Journal of Public Health 43 (2019).
Publisher's VersionAbstractObjectives. The aim of this study was to estimate out-of-pocket expenditures incurred by individuals with HIV in the Dominican Republic. The study utilized different definitions and components for these expenditures and differentiated the results by wage ranges. Methods. Data was obtained from an in-person survey of people living with HIV. The study was developed and implemented in collaboration with Dominican grassroots organizations and networks of people with HIV, through a process of community-based participatory research. Results. The mean HIV-related expenditure reported by individuals in the sample in the last six months prior to the survey was in US$ 181; 15.4% of this total was spent for transportation and housing and costs to access the HIV facility. The mean expenditure reported by individuals for their current visit to an HIV center was US$ 10. These outof- pocket expenditures exhibited regressivity, with lower-wage patients spending proportionally more to receive care. The results highlight the importance of considering other resources required to access treatment, such as lodging expenses and the time needed to travel to an HIV center and then to wait to be seen by a care provider. Conclusions. There should be more focus on expenditures made directly by people with HIV in the Dominican Republic so that these payments do not become a barrier to accessing health care. Using a community-based participatory design can ensure that such data can be leveraged to address the specific barriers to care that are faced by individuals with HIV.
v43e562019.pdf Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “
Why health reforms fail: Lessons from the 2014 Chilean attempt to reform.”
Health Systems & Reform 5, no. 2 (2019): 134-144.
Publisher's VersionAbstractIn 2014 Chile started a process to reform its private health insurance scheme. A Commission was created and released a report with recommendations, but no changes have been introduced yet. This paper analyzes that reform process. The analysis included document review and interviews with key stakeholders involved in the process. Results show that although the Commission failed in producing the intended changes, it contributed to opening the debate regarding the Chilean health system, making explicit the different positions on the issue. The analysis shows that the reform did not advance because of the lack of basic consensus on the Commission’s role, scope, and main purpose among stakeholders. Previous reforms highlight the relevance of time and information in creating a successful reform process.
why_health_reforms_fail_lessons_from_the_2014_chilean_attempt_to_reform.pdf Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “
Panorama de la dependencia en Chile: Avances y desafíos.”
Revista Médica de Chile 147, no. 1 (2019): 83-90.
Publisher's VersionAbstractChile is facing a process of rapid aging which poses several challenges. Among these challenges is the increase of dependency in the population. Despite its rele- vance, the topic has not been prioritized in the agenda. One explanation for this low-priority is the lack of information on the concept of dependency. This article shows that, in fact, no consensus exists in Chile on how to define and measure dependency. Additionally, it provides an updated estimation of dependency in the country, aiming to foster further debate on the topic.
0717-6163-rmc-147-01-0083.pdf