Publications by Type: Journal Article

2019
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo, Thomas J. Bossert, Jim Sherry, and Margaret E Kruk. “A synthesis of implementation science frameworks and application to global health gaps.” Global Health Research and Policy 4, no. 25 (2019). Publisher's VersionAbstract

Background: Implementation science has been growing as discipline in the past decades, producing an increasing number of models in the area. On the other hand, most frameworks are intended to guide the implementation of programs, focusing on identifying elements and stages that increase their success. This article aims to structure this discussion, proposing a simplified tool that synthesizes common elements of other frameworks, and highlight the usefulness to use implementation science not only in identifying successful implementation strategies but as a tool to assess gaps in global health initiatives.

Methods: The study was carried out through a combined methodology that included an initial search of implementation science frameworks, experts’ opinions, and the use of references in frameworks to elaborate a list of articles to be reviewed. A total of 52 articles were analyzed, identifying their definitions of implementation science and the elements of different frameworks.

Results: The analysis of articles allowed identifying the main goals and definitions of implementation science. In a second stage, frameworks were classified into “time-based”, “component-based” and “mixed”, and common elements of each type of model were used to propose a synthetic framework with six elements: Diagnosis, Intervention provider/ system, Intervention, Recipient, Environment, and Evaluation. Finally, this simplified framework was used to identify gaps in global health was using The Lancet Global Health Series. Potential areas of intervention arise for five different global health issues: malaria, non-communicable diseases, maternal and child health, HIV/AIDS, and tuberculosis. Prioritization strategies differ for the different health issues, and the proposed framework can help identify and classify all these different proposals.

Conclusions: There is a huge variety of definitions and models in implementation science. The analysis showed the usefulness of applying an implementation science approach to identify and prioritize gaps in implementation strategies in global health.

s41256-019-0115-1.pdf
Chaumont, Claire, Carlo Oliveira, Enrique Chavez, Jaime Valencia, and Pablo Villalobos Dintrans. “Out-of-pocket expenditures for HIV in the Dominican Republic: findings from a community-based participatory survey.” Pan American Journal of Public Health 43 (2019). Publisher's VersionAbstract
Objectives. The aim of this study was to estimate out-of-pocket expenditures incurred by individuals with HIV in the Dominican Republic. The study utilized different definitions and components for these expenditures and differentiated the results by wage ranges. Methods. Data was obtained from an in-person survey of people living with HIV. The study was developed and implemented in collaboration with Dominican grassroots organizations and networks of people with HIV, through a process of community-based participatory research. Results. The mean HIV-related expenditure reported by individuals in the sample in the last six months prior to the survey was in US$ 181; 15.4% of this total was spent for transportation and housing and costs to access the HIV facility. The mean expenditure reported by individuals for their current visit to an HIV center was US$ 10. These outof- pocket expenditures exhibited regressivity, with lower-wage patients spending proportionally more to receive care. The results highlight the importance of considering other resources required to access treatment, such as lodging expenses and the time needed to travel to an HIV center and then to wait to be seen by a care provider. Conclusions. There should be more focus on expenditures made directly by people with HIV in the Dominican Republic so that these payments do not become a barrier to accessing health care. Using a community-based participatory design can ensure that such data can be leveraged to address the specific barriers to care that are faced by individuals with HIV.
v43e562019.pdf
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “Why health reforms fail: Lessons from the 2014 Chilean attempt to reform.” Health Systems & Reform 5, no. 2 (2019): 134-144. Publisher's VersionAbstract
In 2014 Chile started a process to reform its private health insurance scheme. A Commission was created and released a report with recommendations, but no changes have been introduced yet. This paper analyzes that reform process. The analysis included document review and interviews with key stakeholders involved in the process. Results show that although the Commission failed in producing the intended changes, it contributed to opening the debate regarding the Chilean health system, making explicit the different positions on the issue. The analysis shows that the reform did not advance because of the lack of basic consensus on the Commission’s role, scope, and main purpose among stakeholders. Previous reforms highlight the relevance of time and information in creating a successful reform process.
why_health_reforms_fail_lessons_from_the_2014_chilean_attempt_to_reform.pdf
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “Panorama de la dependencia en Chile: Avances y desafíos.” Revista Médica de Chile 147, no. 1 (2019): 83-90. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Chile is facing a process of rapid aging which poses several challenges. Among these challenges is the increase of dependency in the population. Despite its rele- vance, the topic has not been prioritized in the agenda. One explanation for this low-priority is the lack of information on the concept of dependency. This article shows that, in fact, no consensus exists in Chile on how to define and measure dependency. Additionally, it provides an updated estimation of dependency in the country, aiming to foster further debate on the topic. 

0717-6163-rmc-147-01-0083.pdf
2018
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “Long-term care systems as social security: The case of Chile.” Health Policy and Planning 33, no. 9 (2018): 1018-1025. Publisher's VersionAbstract
Similar to many other countries, Chile is facing the challenges of rapid ageing and the increase in long-term care (LTC) needs for this population. Implementation of LTC systems has been the response to these challenges in other countries, however, Chile still lacks a strategy for addressing LTC needs. This article advocates for the implementation of a LTC system in Chile, demonstrating that this could be an effective and efficient response to cope with the current and future challenges faced by the country. The rationale for implementing a LTC system is based on the principles of the country’s social security system and on the fact that not having a LTC in place is not costless.
czy083.pdf
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “Is aging a problem? Dependency, long-term care, and public policies in Chile.” Pan American Journal of Public Health 42 (2018): e168. Publisher's VersionAbstract
Chile is facing changes associated with the demographic transition. So far, these challenges have been framed as age related. This has contributed to approaching a broad set of issues from a narrow perspective. The focus on aging has fragmented a multidisciplinary problem into different parts—particularly health and social policies—with different actors dealing with it from the perspective of their own sector. This process has generated an incomplete picture, preventing the definition and measurement of dependency and long-term care, and hindering a coordinated response to these issues. This article advocates for a change in the definition of the problem, by adopting the concept of long-term care, in order to gain a deeper and more comprehensive perspective on the issues arising from the situation that Chile is experiencing.
v42e1682018.pdf
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “Do long-term care services match population needs? A spatial analysis of nursing homes in Chile.” PLoS ONE 13, no. 6 (2018): e0199522. Publisher's VersionAbstract
Chile is experiencing a period of rapid aging, which increases the need of long-term care services in the country. Nursing homes have been the traditional alternative to deal with the increase of elderly population in the country, with services supplied by a mix of for-profit and nonprofit providers. Additionally, population exhibits a high degree of geographical concentration. The study aims to identify the determinants of the geographical location of nursing homes in Chile at municipality level. The analysis takes into account the different location criteria for different types of nursing homes as well as potential spatial effects. The paper uses spatial analysis tools to identify clusters of nursing homes and population characteristics and to estimate the determinants of nursing homes availability and coverage in the country. The analysis–based on spatial global and local tests, and spatial autoregressive models- show the existence of clusters of nursing homes as well as clusters of municipalities according to elderly population, income, poverty, population density, and public health insurance coverage. Residuals from ordinary least squares regressions were spatially autocorrelated, showing the need of using spatial models. Estimations show that availability and coverage of nursing homes are positively related with municipality income, and that for-profit and nonprofit facilities respond differently to different factors. A negative coefficient was found for poverty in nonprofit nursing homes, raising doubts about the effectiveness of giving public subsidies to incentive the installation of facilities in areas with high needs and low income.
journal.pone_.0199522.pdf
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “Out-of-pocket health expenditure differences in Chile: Insurance performance or selection?Health Policy 122, no. 2 (2018): 184-191. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Chile has a mixed health system with public and private actors engaged in provision and insurance.This dual system generates important differences in health expenditure between private and public insurances. Selection is a preeminent feature of the Chilean insurance system. In order to explain the role of the insurance in out-of-pocket expenditures between households for different insurance schemes,decomposition methods are applied to disentangle the effect of household ‘composition and insurance’degree of financial protection on health expenditures. Health expenditure patterns have not changed inthe last 10 years with drugs, outpatient care, and dental health representing 60% of the health expenditure. Health expenditure/income is similar for different income groups in the public insurance, but decreases with income in households with private coverage, reflecting regressivity in health expenditure. On the other hand, health expenditure as share of expenditure increases with income for both groups. Per capita health expenditure in households with private coverage is four times the expenditure of households with public insurance; this gap is mostly explained by differences in households’ expenditureand demographics. Roughly 80% of the difference in expenditure is explained by the model, showing the role of selection in understanding the expenditure gap between insurance schemes.

2017
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “Envejecimiento y cuidados a largo plazo en Chile: Desafíos en el contexto OCDE.” Pan American Journal of Public Health 41 (2017): e86. Publisher's VersionAbstract
Chile is fully in the process of demographic transition, with a rapidly aging population. This situation poses multiple public policy challenges, including those in the public health sector. Specifically, the association between aging and the loss of autonomy calls for the rapid design of a long-term care policy in the country. The purpose of this article is to describe Chile’s current situation with respect to long-term care in aging, using the experience of the countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development to draw attention to the need to move forward with the design and financing of a coordinated policy in the country that will permit early action to meet the challenges of aging in the coming decades.
v41a862017.pdf
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo, and Claire Chaumont. “Examining the relationship between human resources and mortality: the effects of methodological choices.” International Journal of Public Health 62, no. 3 (2017): 361-370. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Objectives

Relationship between human resources for health and mortality remains inconclusive despite numerous studies published on the topic in the last decades. This paper investigates how and why methodological trade-offs implicitly made by researchers when using macro-data can in part explains this puzzling lack of agreement.

Methods

Using data from the Global Health Observatory, we build a model of the relationship between human resources and mortality, which we progressively alter by changing its scope, variables and analysis period. Then, we compare results among themselves to isolate the impact of methodological choices from other changes in the data.

Results

Results demonstrate how methodological choices linked to (1) the analysis period, (2) the definition of health inputs, health outcomes and control variables and (3) the choice of specific variables as proxy for human resources and health outcomes affects the relationship between human resources and health outputs.

Conclusions

Results presented highlights the need for complementing existing macro-analysis with other analytical strategies, for better documenting methodological choices in research studies, as well as for further supporting countries’ efforts to produce reliable and consistent data.

2015
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “El mercado de las farmacias en Chile: ¿Competencia por localización?Economía y Política 2, no. 3 (2015): 33-73. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Competition in the Chilean drugstore market has been recently disputed, based on a price-fixing case involving the three major drugstore chains. However, firms also compete in other dimensions such as geographical location of stores. Using an original dataset, this paper describes the geographical distribution of the three major pharmacy chains’ stores at national, regional and municipal level. The results show that: i) drugstores tend to agglomerate in certain geographical areas; ii) there are many municipalities in which the three main drugstore chains do not have a single store and; iii) one of the firms (Cruz Verde) has a location strategy different from its competitors. The goal of the paper is to describe the national drugstore market, understood as a first step to identify the way in which firms do (or do not) compete by location, as well as its implications for consumers. 

n1-02-villalobos.pdf
2014
Villalobos Dintrans, Pablo. “Demographic Transition and Public Policy: Chile 1850-2000.” Economic Analysis Review 29, no. 1 (2014): 77-110. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Chile has experienced tremendous changes over the past centuries. Notwithstanding the importance of many of these transformations, the demographic change has been crucial, given its influence on the whole Chilean society. This paper inquires into the effects of the Chilean demographic transition on the fiscal policies implemented by the government throughout a 150 years period. The results suggest a correlation between demographic variables and fiscal expenditure on different goods. Particularly, the estimations find a positive impact of a younger population on educational expenditure and negative effects of the share of adult population on fiscal expenditures.

401-1315-2-pb-2.pdf
2013
Castillo-Laborde, Carla, and Pablo Villalobos Dintrans. “Caracterización del gasto de bolsillo en Chile: Una mirada a dos sistemas.” Rev Med Chile 141, no. 11 (2013): 1449-1456. Publisher's Version art13.pdf
2010
Jara, J. Joaquín, Patricio Pérez, and Pablo Villalobos Dintrans. “Good deposits are not enough: Mining labor productivity analysis in the copper industry in Chile and Peru, 1992-2009.” Resources Policy 35, no. 4 (2010): 247-256. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Chile and Peru produce almost 45% of world’s mine copper output. This situation reflects their natural endowment and mining tradition, but is also the result of development processes undertaken over the last decades. As a result, both countries multiplied its mine copper production in more than 3 times in the last 20 years. Mining labor productivity played a central role achieving these amazing growth rates. Although there is a consensus about the relevance of this variable for the mining industry, the specific factors behind labor productivity changes are not completely understood.

In this paper we use a panel data approach to analyze labor productivity in the copper mining sector in Chile and Peru from 1992 to 2009. This technique is consistent with heterogeneity among mines and allows us to identify, describe and analyze all the different sources behind labor productivity changes.

The result of the analysis shows that better deposits and operational factors are important, but not enough to explain labor productivity improvements in the copper mining industry, and instead, company specific efforts and wide industry changes, such as technology and management innovations, are as important as the evolution of the reserve base or geological features of the operations.

Pérez, Patricio, and Pablo Villalobos. “¿Por qué subcontratan las empresas mineras en Chile?Estudios Públicos 119 (2010).Abstract

Los datos disponibles muestran que el fenómeno de la sub- contratación ha cobrado fuerza al interior de las empresas, caracterizando la evolución del mercado del trabajo en los úl- timos años. La minería no ha estado ajena a este fenómeno. A mediados de los años noventa por cada trabajador propio había 0,68 trabajadores contratistas, mientras una década después la relación es de casi dos trabajadores externos por cada trabaja- dor propio.

este trabajo analiza las causas de la subcontratación en la mi- nería del cobre en Chile. se usan datos de panel para 18 faenas en el período 2003-2008. se concluye que los precios, las pre- siones de costos y el tamaño de la planta son importantes para explicar los niveles de subcontratación. 

rev119_perez_villalobos.pdf

Pages