Bias and Judging

Citation:

Harris, Allison P., and Maya Sen. 2019. “Bias and Judging.” Annual Review of Political Science 22: 241-259. Copy at https://j.mp/2or9zed
bias-judging-arps.pdf142 KB

Date Published:

2019

Abstract:

How do we know whether judges of different backgrounds are "biased"? We review the substantial political science literature on judicial decision-making, paying close attention to how judges' demographics and ideology can influence or structure their decision-making. As the research shows, characteristics such as race, ethnicity, and gender can sometimes predict judicial decision-making in limited kinds of cases; however, the literature also suggests that these are by far less important in shaping or predicting outcomes than is ideology (or partisanship), which in turn correlates closely with gender, race, and ethnicity. This leads us to conclude that assuming judges of different backgrounds are biased because they rule differently is questionable: given that the application of the law rarely provides a ``correct'' answer, it is no surprise that judges' decisions vary according to their personal backgrounds and, more importantly, according to their ideology.

Publisher's Version

Last updated on 10/10/2019