Publications

2017
Erb-Satullo NL, Gilmour BJJ, Khakhutaishvili N. Copper production landscapes of the South Caucasus. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology. 2017;47 :109-126. Publisher's VersionAbstract
Studies of metal production frequently show a correlation between scale and organizational complexity. The remarkably rich landscapes of metal-producing sites of late 2nd-early 1st millennium BC Colchis provide an unprecedented opportunity to reexamine this apparent correlation. Investigations of copper smelting sites show that industries with a large aggregate output can be the result of numerous small groups of metalworkers acting independently. Spatial data on site distributions, estimates of productive output, and archaeometric data on ore procurement patterns were integrated to reconstruct the organization of production. Judicious use of a portable X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (pXRF) showed that not only were smelting sites highly dispersed, but also that metalworkers at different sites were using ores from geologically distinct deposits. This innovative approach helped to reconstruct the organization of production in a distinctive metal production landscape, bridging an enduring divide between landscape-scale and microscopic investigations of craft production.
Erb-Satullo NL, Walton JT. Iron and copper production at Iron Age Ashkelon: Implications for the organization of Levantine metal production. Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports. 2017;15 :8-19. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Understanding the spatial distribution of different craft production activities is an essential part of any investigation into the organization of production. In the Iron Age southern Levant, discussions of the rise of iron often revolve around the relative organization of bronze and iron production. For these reasons, identifying where different stages of metal production occurred is essential for testing models of technological change during this period.

This study reviews the challenges of identifying different stages of metal production from often-ephemeral residues found at settlement sites, with particular emphasis on the question of urban iron smelting in the early Iron Age southern Levant. These considerations are applied to the analysis of a small but significant assemblage of metal production remains from Iron IIB Ashkelon (c. 8th century BCE), using macroscopic observations, chemical analysis, and microscopy.

The results of these analyses support the conclusion that multiple iron production processes—likely including both smelting and smithing—took place in or near a domestic quarter at Ashkelon. With one or two exceptions, copper production residues are restricted to secondary refining and casting residues. Copper smelting was carried out elsewhere. If this pattern holds as more urban production debris is recognized and analyzed, such differences in the relative organization of iron and copper-alloy production may provide clues as to why iron production expanded dramatically in the early 1st millennium BCE.

2014
Erb-Satullo N, Gilmour BJJ, Khakhutaishvili N. Late Bronze Age and Early Iron Age copper smelting technologies in the South Caucasus: The view from ancient Colchis c. 1500-600 BC. Journal of Archaeological Science. 2014;49 :147-159. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Many of the arguments for how and why people began to use iron in Southwest Asia rely on assumptions about the technology and relative organization of copper and iron smelting. However, research on the technological transformations of the Late Bronze Age and Early Iron Age suffers from a lack of investigation of primary metal production contexts, especially in regions outside the Levant. The current research examines metal production debris from a large number of smelting sites in western Georgia, and addresses questions of technology and resource utilization through detailed examination of few select sites. Through the chemical and mineralogical analysis of slag samples, we demonstrate the existence of an extensive copper-production industry and reconstruct several key aspects of the smelting technology during the Late Bronze Age and Early Iron Age. Combining a statistical analysis of slag mineralogy with other lines of evidence, we argue that copper was extracted from sulfide ores through a process of roasting and smelting in deep pit furnaces. The data also suggest that metalworkers at different sites exploited different ore sources within the same ore body. These results form a fundamental basis for further examination of spatial and chronological patterns of technological variation, with implications for models of Near Eastern copper production in this crucial period. Intriguing evidence of bloomery iron smelting, though currently undated, reinforces the region’s potential to provide data on a key technological transformation.

2012
Eremin K, Degryse P, Erb-Satullo N, Ganio M, Greene J, Shortland A, Walton M, Stager L. Iron Age glass beads from Carthage. In: Meeks ND, Meek A, Mongiatti A, Cartwright C Historical technology, materials, and conservation: SEM and microanalysis. London: Archetype Publications and the British Museum ; 2012. pp. 30-35.Abstract

A large number of glass beads were found within urns containing the cremated remains of children and occasionally animals from the Carthage Tophet, dating to the eighth to fourth century BC. The glass beads were analysed to determine their composition and microstructure to identify the alkali source used and assist with determining the likely provenance of the beads. The main analytical technique used was scanning electron microscopy with energy dispersive microanalysis with additional techniques including X-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy to more closely characterise the individual phases and matrix glass. This paper concentrates on the most common bead types, which were characterised by high iron contents and high levels of crystalline phases, including magnetite, hematite, wollastonite, wuestite, and barium sulfate. The glass was extrememly vessicular and contained remnant quartz and (rarely) feldspar. Many samples showed extensive alteration, evident from both the microstructure and the composition. These beads represent some of the earliest natron glass known from a firm context, although absolute dates are lacking. The most likely scenario for the manufacture of these beads is local production from imported glass, which was probably colored locally with iron-rich metallurgical waste.

ereminetal_2012_ironagebeadcarthage.pdf
2011
Erb-Satullo NL. Alloys from Anau: The Manipulation of Metallic Properties in 3rd Millennium B.C. Southern Central Asia. In: Vandiver P, Li W, Ruvalcaba Sil JL, Reedy CL, Frame LD Materials Issues in Art and Archaeology IX. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press ; 2011. pp. 157-163. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Metallography, chemical analysis, and microhardness testing of copper-alloy objects from Anau, Turkmenistan (c. 3000-2400 B.C.), were undertaken to determine how technological choices influenced the properties of the finished objects. Additionally, this analytical program assessed the position of the Anau metals in the development of metallurgy in southern Central Asia. Metallographic analysis of three bladed objects, all copper-arsenic alloys with 1 % to 5% arsenic, showed that their edges had been cold-worked to a greater or lesser degree to create a blade that maintained a sharp edge, but also had flexibility to withstand impacts. Microhardness testing confirmed that the blade edges had a higher hardness than the interior metal. One of the objects had sulfur-rich inclusions in the metal matrix, suggesting the original charge had at least
some sulfide ore. Conversely, a curved rod, made from a copper-lead-tin alloy, was cast to shape and showed no additional working of the metal. Lead, visible as black particles in the microstructure, was likely added to make the molten metal flow more easily. The metallographic and chemical analyses showed that the Anau objects fit into the tradition of Southern Central Asian metallurgy, though the presence of tin in objects of this period is more rare here than in
later periods. Anau smiths displayed an ability to manipulate both physical and chemical properties of metal in order to produce functional objects with optimal characteristics.

erb-satullo_2011_alloysanau.pdf
Erb-Satullo NL, Shortland AJ, Eremin K. Chemical and mineralogical approaches to the organization of Late Bronze Age Nuzi Ware production. Archaeometry. 2011;53 :1171-1192. Publisher's VersionAbstract

In order to investigate the nature and organization of high-status ceramic production in the Late Bronze Age, samples of Nuzi Ware from four different sites were analysed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM–EDS) and inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP–AES). Chemical and mineralogical evidence suggests that Nuzi Ware was produced in at least two distinct regions, one probably in the Adhaim Basin in northern Iraq and another possibly in the Orontes catchment in southeastern Turkey. The existence of individual production units probably developed in response to the local elites’ desire to imitate the tastes of the Mitanni aristocracy, resulting in a mapping of political relationships on to material culture .

erb-satulloetal_2011_chemminappnuziwareprod.pdf
2010
McKitterick CB, Erb-Satullo NL, LaRacuente ND, Dickinson AJ, Collings PJ. Aggregation properties of the chromonic liquid crystal Benzopurpurin 4B. Journal of Physical Chemistry B. 2010;114 :1888-1896. Publisher's VersionAbstract

Optical polarization, absorption, and scattering studies along with confocal microscopy reveal that Benzopurpurin 4B forms aggregates of micrometer size at very low concentrations in aqueous solution. A chromonic liquid crystal phase is stable at room temperature down to concentrations as low as 0.4 wt %, which can only be possible if the aggregates contain an ample amount of water. The kinetics of aggregate formation are extremely slow, with changes going on for days before equilibrium is reached. The stacking free energy change is estimated to be 10.3 ± 0.4 kBT, which is in the higher range of values for recently studied chromonic liquid crystals. However, the very low concentration of the liquid crystal phase puts it in a different class, probably more similar to Scheibe or Jelly aggregates than the typical chromonic systems that are formed by simple stacks of molecules.

Degryse P, Boyce A, Erb-Satullo N, Eremin K, Kirk S, Scott R, Shortland AJ, Schneider J, Walton M. Isotopic discriminants between Late Bronze Age glasses from Egypt and the Near East. Archaeometry. 2010;52 :380-388.